Best picks

9 Best Frigidaire Ice Makers (November 2026)

Updated on · By the Cooksmithy team

The best Frigidaire ice makers include the Frigidaire Countertop Portable for everyday countertop ice, the EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop for chewable nugget ice, and the Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker for refrigerator replacement.

On this page (5 sections)
  1. Which Frigidaire ice maker is best for most homes?
  2. Best Frigidaire ice maker picks compared
  3. How do you choose the best Frigidaire ice maker?
  4. What if a Frigidaire ice maker stops making ice?
  5. Which Frigidaire ice maker should you buy?

The best Frigidaire ice maker for most homes is the Frigidaire Countertop Portable, which makes up to 26 lb of bullet-shaped ice per day and offers 2 ice sizes.

Choose the EFIC452-SS for clear square ice and higher output, or the Nurfosttek replacement when your refrigerator's built-in ice maker needs a compatible replacement.

Countertop machines add ice without requiring a new refrigerator. They sit on a counter, make ice in batches, and leave your existing fridge in place.

For a built-in installation, compare undercounter ice makers for home.

That route suits a planned kitchen or bar setup where a fixed unit can live under a counter and connect to a water supply.

Before choosing one, compare the ice style, water tank, basket size, counter footprint and controls with your daily use.

Small details matter here, such as whether you drink mostly soda, cocktails or iced coffee, and how often you refill and empty the machine.

If you are still deciding between machine types, this ice maker for home buying guide explains the main choices.

For a smaller appliance category, compare these best countertop ice makers before you settle on a model.

Our picks at a glance

  1. 1 Frigidaire Countertop Portable
    Best for everyday countertop ice

    Frigidaire Countertop Portable

    9.6/10 our score

    See it on Amazon
  2. 2 EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop
    Best for chewable nugget ice

    EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop

    9.6/10 our score

    See it on Amazon
  3. 3 Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker
    Best for refrigerator replacement

    Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker

    9.5/10 our score

    See it on Amazon
  1. 4FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker

    FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker

    Best for clear cube countertop ice
    Check it
  2. 5Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact

    Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact

    Best for a smaller counter depth
    Check it
  3. 6FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker

    FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker

    Best for simple black countertop use
    Check it
  4. 7Frigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top Maker

    Frigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top Maker

    Best for a compact stainless finish
    Check it
  5. 8FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact Ice Maker Machine

    FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact Ice Maker Machine

    Best for a blue retro finish
    Check it
  6. 9FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS 40 Lbs Extra Large Clear

    FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS 40 Lbs Extra Large Clear

    Best for clear square ice and parties
    Check it

Which Frigidaire ice maker is best for most homes?

The Frigidaire Countertop Portable is the best overall pick because it combines 26 lb daily output, 2 ice sizes, a 2.1 qt tank and a transparent window.

It suits regular drinks, small gatherings, offices and dorm rooms without moving into the larger size of the 40 lb model.

That balance is the reason it sits at the top for most homes. You get steady batch ice through the day, and the two sizes cover tall glasses and smaller drinks without a separate machine.

The 2.1 qt tank helps between refills, which matters when you are cooking, serving guests or working away from the counter.

The transparent window gives a quick read on ice level, and the digital LED controls keep size selection in one place.

The score weighs specs, features and buyer feedback against what you are shopping for.

In plain terms, it rewards the needs most buyers have first, which are reliable daily ice, simple controls and a footprint that fits a normal kitchen counter.

It is less suited to buyers whose top priority is clear square ice, soft nugget ice or a built-in refrigerator part.

For those needs, the picks below offer a cleaner match on ice style or installation type.

ProductBest forDaily outputSizeIce styleOur score
Frigidaire Countertop Portableeveryday countertop ice26 lb15 x 11 x 14.5 inBullet-shaped9.6
EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertopchewable nugget ice44 lb13.9 x 9.85 x 14.95 inSoft chewable nugget9.6
Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Makerrefrigerator replacement11.6 x 4.6 x 4.8 in9.5
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Makerclear cube countertop ice26 lb15 x 11 x 14.5 inSquared clear cubes9.4
Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compacta smaller counter depth26 lb9 x 13 x 13 inBullet-shaped9.4
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Makersimple black countertop use26 lb12 x 11 x 14.5 inCountertop ice cubes9.3
Frigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top Makera compact stainless finish26 lb12.3 x 8.7 x 12.5 inBullet-shaped9.1
FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact Ice Maker Machinea blue retro finish26 lb11.6 x 8.7 x 11.4 in8.4
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS 40 Lbs Extra Large Clearclear square ice and parties40 lb14 x 11 x 15 inClear square8.0

Best Frigidaire ice maker picks compared

The 9 products below cover 3 different buying needs: portable countertop machines, clear-ice models and a refrigerator replacement part. The EUHOMY is included as a nugget-ice alternative because Frigidaire's products here focus on bullet or square ice.

Frigidaire Countertop Portable: best for everyday countertop ice

1

Frigidaire Countertop Portable: Best for everyday countertop ice

Frigidaire Countertop Portable, Frigidaire ice makers
9.6/10Our score
  • 26 lb per day
  • 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes
  • 2 ice sizes
  • 2.1 qt water tank
  • Transparent window and digital LED controls

This portable Frigidaire makes 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes and offers 2 ice sizes. Its 2.1 qt tank and drain plug suit regular home, office or dorm use.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • 26 lb daily output
  • 2 ice sizes
  • 2.1 qt water tank
  • Ice scoop included

Cons

  • Ice basket holds 1.5 lb
  • Does not make clear square ice

The Frigidaire Countertop Portable is the strongest general-purpose choice in this group. It makes 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes, with 2 size options for different drinks.

Its 26 lb per day output is enough for regular household use and small events. The 2.1 qt tank reduces refill frequency, while the transparent window lets you see the ice level and the active ice-making area.

The digital LED control panel keeps the main choices together. The interior basket holds up to 1.5 lb, and the included ice scoop helps move cubes from the basket to a glass or cooler.

The drain plug matters during cleanup because it gives you a way to empty the unit. The stated dimensions are 15 x 11 x 14.5 in, so measure the counter and the space needed around the machine before setting it up.

Choose this model when you want a balanced Frigidaire ice maker for daily drinks. Pick another product if you specifically want nugget ice, clear square ice or a built-in refrigerator replacement.

Frigidaire Countertop PortableCheck it on Amazon

EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop: best for chewable ice

2

EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop: Best for chewable nugget ice

EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop, Frigidaire ice makers
9.6/10Our score
  • 44 lb per day
  • Nugget ice ready in 7 to 10 minutes
  • 1.8 L water tank
  • 20-minute self-cleaning cycle
  • One-touch controls

The EUHOMY makes soft, chewable nugget ice and has the highest stated daily output in this roundup. It is a useful alternative when ice texture matters more than staying with the Frigidaire brand.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • 44 lb daily output
  • Nugget ice texture
  • Self-cleaning cycle
  • Compact footprint

Cons

  • Not a Frigidaire model
  • 1.8 L tank is smaller than some Frigidaire tanks

The EUHOMY is the right choice when soft, chewable nugget ice matters more than the Frigidaire name. It makes up to 44 lb per day and produces nugget ice in 7 to 10 minutes.

Its 1.8 L tank is smaller than the 2.1 qt tanks on some Frigidaire machines, but the stated output is higher. One-touch controls keep operation simple, and the LIGHT button illuminates the chamber for low-light use.

A 20-minute self-cleaning cycle is the main care feature. For a tablet-based cleaning method, see ice maker cleaner tablets.

The machine measures 13.9 x 9.85 x 14.95 in and includes an ice scoop and manual.

This is not a Frigidaire model, so choose it only if the ice texture and output are more important than matching the brand. You can also compare it with our best Euhomy ice maker machine guide.

EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker CountertopCheck it on Amazon

Nurfosttek 241798224: best for a refrigerator replacement

3

Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker: Best for refrigerator replacement

Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker, Frigidaire ice makers
9.5/10Our score
  • Replacement ice maker for listed Frigidaire and Kenmore models
  • Automatic water filling
  • Automatic start and stop
  • Adjustable ice size
  • Four-step installation

This is a refrigerator replacement part, not a countertop machine. It fits buyers whose Frigidaire or Kenmore refrigerator matches the listed model and part-number requirements.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • Automatic water filling
  • Adjustable ice size
  • Compact replacement form
  • Food-grade materials

Cons

  • Compatibility must be checked carefully
  • Not a portable countertop ice maker

The Nurfosttek is for a different problem than the countertop machines. It is a replacement ice maker for compatible Frigidaire and Kenmore refrigerators, with part number 241798224 and a stated 2 lb capacity.

Its automatic water filling and start-stop function are intended for refrigerator installation. The ice size is adjustable, and the unit measures 11.6 x 4.6 x 4.8 in.

Compatibility is the key decision. If the built-in unit is compatible but has a water-supply problem, compare Frigidaire ice maker water inlet valves.

Check your refrigerator model and the listed replacement part numbers before ordering, because a countertop machine cannot replace a built-in refrigerator ice maker.

The installation outline uses 4 steps: disconnect power, remove the old machine, connect the replacement and reinstall the components. The product data states that a 1/4 in screwdriver is needed and describes the process as possible without special tools.

Choose this part only when your refrigerator model matches. For operating instructions after installation, see how to use a Frigidaire ice maker.

Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice MakerCheck it on Amazon

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver: best for clear cube countertop ice

4

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker: Best for clear cube countertop ice

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice Maker, Frigidaire ice makers
9.4/10Our score
  • 26 lb per day
  • Clear ice cubes
  • 2 ice sizes
  • 2.2 lb storage capacity
  • Transparent window and electronic controls

The EFIC189 makes clear, squared cubes and stores up to 2.2 lb at a time. Its 26 lb daily output fits households that want a classic countertop machine with a silver stainless steel finish.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • Clear squared ice
  • 2.2 lb storage
  • 26 lb daily output
  • 2 ice sizes

Cons

  • Same broad footprint as some larger countertop models
  • Not nugget ice

The EFIC189-Silver is the better fit for buyers who prefer clear squared ice cubes over bullet-shaped ice.

It produces up to 26 lb per day and stores up to 2.2 lb at a time.

The machine offers 2 ice sizes and has electronic controls for operation. Its transparent window lets you watch the ice-making area, while the controls indicate when the basket is full or the water is empty.

That window is useful during a party or a busy evening, since you can see progress without opening the lid and losing time.

Set up is straightforward for a countertop unit. Place it on a level surface, add water to the reservoir beneath the basket, choose a size, and let the first cycle run.

Care is mostly about keeping the reservoir clean and moving finished ice out of the basket before it melts and sits in the meltwater.

At 15 x 11 x 14.5 in, it has the same stated dimensions as the black stainless portable pick. Its stainless steel material and silver finish give it a different counter appearance, but the daily output is similar.

Choose it for clear, squared ice and a 2.2 lb basket. If you need chewable ice, the EUHOMY is a closer match.

For another countertop brand, compare Igloo ice makers.

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC189-Silver Compact Ice MakerCheck it on Amazon

Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact: best for a narrower setup

5

Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact: Best for a smaller counter depth

Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact, Frigidaire ice makers
9.4/10Our score
  • 26 lb per day
  • 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes
  • 2 ice sizes
  • Transparent window and digital LED controls
  • 2.1 qt water tank

This portable Frigidaire makes bullet-shaped ice with 2 size choices and a 2.1 qt tank. Its stated 9 x 13 x 13 in dimensions make it worth measuring against a tight counter area.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • 26 lb daily output
  • 2.1 qt water tank
  • 2 ice sizes
  • Transparent window

Cons

  • Included components list only the ice maker
  • Bullet ice is not clear or nugget ice

This portable compact model is a strong option when your available space is shaped differently from the standard 15 x 11 x 14.5 in machines.

Its stated dimensions are 9 x 13 x 13 in, with 26 lb daily output.

It makes 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes and offers 2 size options. The 2.1 qt tank supports repeated cycles, while the transparent window and digital LED controls help you see the ice level and choose the ice size.

For daily use, the cycle time means you can plan around short batches rather than waiting for a large bin to fill. The smaller size choice suits mixed drinks, and the larger helps with tall glasses.

The product data lists the included component as the ice maker. Measure the counter depth, width and height carefully, then leave room for normal access to the controls and water tank.

A shallower depth on paper still needs space behind the unit for ventilation and power. Check the height against cabinets above the counter before you commit to a spot.

Empty and drain the tank when you are done for the day, and wipe down water-contact areas to keep the ice tasting clean.

Choose this model when its dimensions fit your counter better than the other 26 lb Frigidaire machines. It is not the right pick for clear square or nugget ice.

Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable CompactCheck it on Amazon

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK: best for simple black countertop use

6

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker: Best for simple black countertop use

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker, Frigidaire ice makers
9.3/10Our score
  • 26 lb per day
  • 9 cubes every 5 to 6 minutes
  • Transparent window
  • Full-basket and low-water indicators
  • Recycles melted water into fresh ice

The EFIC128AMZBLK combines a black finish with 26 lb daily output and indicator lights for a full basket or low water. Transfer finished ice to a freezer because this unit makes ice but does not keep it frozen.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • 26 lb daily output
  • 5 to 6 minute cycles
  • Full-basket and low-water alerts
  • Compact dimensions

Cons

  • Ice storage is not frozen storage
  • Refrigerant information is not specified

The EFIC128AMZBLK offers a black countertop design with 26 lb per day output and cycles that produce 9 cubes every 5 to 6 minutes.

It measures 12 x 11 x 14.5 in. That compact size suits a home bar, kitchen or office.

The transparent window shows the ice level. Indicators remind you when the basket is full or the water is low.

This machine recycles water from melted ice into a fresh batch. It makes ice rather than storing it frozen, so move finished ice to a freezer promptly if you need it to stay solid.

Set it on a level counter with room to open the lid and lift the basket. Keep the area clear so the controls and window stay easy to use.

Choose it for a black Frigidaire machine with clear operating reminders. Its 105 W rating is lower than the 1,000 W ratings shown for some other products in this group.

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice MakerCheck it on Amazon

Frigidaire EFIC123-SS: best for a compact stainless finish

7

Frigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top Maker: Best for a compact stainless finish

Frigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top Maker, Frigidaire ice makers
9.1/10Our score
  • 26 lb per day
  • 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes
  • 1.9 qt water tank
  • 2 ice sizes
  • Drain plug and digital LED controls

The EFIC123-SS is a compact stainless steel option with 26 lb daily output and a 1.9 qt tank. Its 12.3 x 8.7 x 12.5 in dimensions can work where larger countertop machines leave little room.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • Small stated footprint
  • 26 lb daily output
  • 2 ice sizes
  • Drain plug

Cons

  • Smaller tank than the 2.1 qt models
  • Bullet-shaped ice only

The EFIC123-SS combines a stainless steel finish with a smaller stated footprint of 12.3 x 8.7 x 12.5 in.

It still produces up to 26 lb per day and makes 9 bullet-shaped cubes every 7 minutes.

Its 1.9 qt water tank is slightly smaller than the 2.1 qt tank on the top pick. It offers 2 ice sizes, a transparent window, digital LED controls and a drain plug for emptying and cleaning.

The smaller tank is a fair trade for the reduced footprint. You may refill a little more often during a long session, but the machine fits counters where larger models crowd out prep space.

The basket holds up to 1.5 lb. That makes the unit useful for a steady supply of drinks, but it does not act as long-term frozen storage.

For care, use the drain plug to empty the tank after a session and let the interior dry before storage. Wipe the basket and water area regularly so residue does not build up.

Place it where you can reach the controls and lid without moving other appliances. A narrow width helps on a busy counter, yet you still need depth for the lid and tank access.

Choose this model when counter space and stainless appearance both matter. Measure the 8.7 in stated width against the space where you plan to place the machine.

Frigidaire EFIC123-SS Counter Top MakerCheck it on Amazon

FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact: best for a blue finish

8

FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact Ice Maker Machine: Best for a blue retro finish

FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact Ice Maker Machine, Frigidaire ice makers
8.4/10Our score
  • 26 lb per day
  • 2 ice sizes
  • 2.2 lb storage capacity
  • Transparent window
  • Full-basket and low-water indicators

The retro compact machine pairs a blue finish with 26 lb daily output and 2 ice sizes. Its 11.6 x 8.7 x 11.4 in size is the smallest stated cabinet in this group.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • Smallest stated cabinet
  • 26 lb daily output
  • 2.2 lb storage
  • Blue finish

Cons

  • Plastic material
  • Ice must be moved to a freezer to prevent melting

The Retro Compact stands out for its blue finish and its smaller stated cabinet size of 11.6 x 8.7 x 11.4 in.

It makes up to 26 lb per day and offers 2 ice sizes.

The basket stores up to 2.2 lb, which is more than the 1.5 lb basket listed for several 26 lb bullet-ice models. The transparent window and indicators show the ice level and alert you when the basket is full or the water is low.

That larger basket is useful for several rounds of drinks. It also means you should still move ice to a freezer if you need it to stay solid beyond a short serving window.

Its plastic material and retro color make it a style-led choice. The machine makes ice but does not keep it frozen.

The compact cabinet suits a dorm, office nook or small kitchen. Keep in mind that the lid and controls still need comfortable reach.

For routine care, empty the tank through the drain and clean the basket area. Fresh water each session keeps the ice cleaner in taste.

Choose it for a compact blue Frigidaire machine with a larger stated basket. Choose the EFIC123-SS instead if a stainless finish is more important.

FRIGIDAIRE Retro Compact Ice Maker MachineCheck it on Amazon

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS: best for clear square ice and parties

9

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS 40 Lbs Extra Large Clear: Best for clear square ice and parties

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS 40 Lbs Extra Large Clear, Frigidaire ice makers
8.0/10Our score
  • 40 lb per day
  • 24 square cubes in less than 15 minutes
  • 2 ice sizes
  • 2.3 qt water tank
  • 2.4 lb basket capacity

The EFIC452-SS offers the highest Frigidaire daily output here at 40 lb and makes clear square ice. Its larger 2.3 qt tank and 2.4 lb basket suit gatherings that need more ice on hand.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • 40 lb daily output
  • Clear square ice
  • Largest Frigidaire tank here
  • 2.4 lb basket

Cons

  • Largest stated cabinet
  • Lower score for buyers who need a small daily machine

The EFIC452-SS is the high-output Frigidaire choice here. It makes up to 40 lb of clear square ice per day, produces 24 cubes in less than 15 minutes and stores up to 2.4 lb in its basket.

Its 2.3 qt water tank is the largest among the Frigidaire countertop products in this roundup. The machine also offers 2 ice sizes, a transparent window, digital LCD controls and a drain plug.

The higher output and larger tank suit gatherings where several people need ice for drinks, coolers or serving bowls. Clear square cubes also look neat in glasses and melt more slowly in some chilled drinks.

At 14 x 11 x 15 in, it is larger than most of the 26 lb options. Plan for the extra height and depth before choosing it for a counter beneath cabinets.

Measure the space under upper cabinets with the lid in mind, since you need room to add water and remove the basket. A spot on an open counter or kitchen island avoids that squeeze.

Use the drain plug after a party or a long day of use, and clean the tank area before storing the machine. Keeping the water path clean helps the next batch taste fresh.

Choose this model for gatherings, larger ice demand or clear square cubes. The smaller Frigidaire machines make more sense when you have limited counter space or only need ice for everyday drinks.

FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS 40 Lbs Extra Large ClearCheck it on Amazon

How do you choose the best Frigidaire ice maker?

Choose the best Frigidaire ice maker by matching the ice style and daily output to your routine first. Then compare the tank, basket, dimensions, controls and cleanup features.

Bullet ice or clear square ice?

Bullet ice is the common choice in the 26 lb Frigidaire countertop machines. The EFIC189-Silver and EFIC452-SS are the better matches when you want clear, squared ice instead.

Ice style affects drinks and storage more than the brand name does. If you want soft, chewable pieces, compare the EUHOMY nugget model rather than choosing among Frigidaire bullet and square machines.

How much output do you need?

A 26 lb per day machine fits regular household drinks and smaller gatherings. The EFIC452-SS raises the stated output to 40 lb, while the EUHOMY reaches 44 lb but makes nugget ice.

Daily output is not the same as frozen storage. Countertop ice makers make ice in batches, and several products here state that finished ice can melt unless you move it to a freezer.

Which tank and basket size make sense?

The Frigidaire machines here range from a 1.9 qt tank on the EFIC123-SS to a 2.3 qt tank on the EFIC452-SS. Larger tanks can reduce refill frequency during repeated cycles.

Basket capacity also varies. The EFIC452-SS stores up to 2.4 lb, while the Frigidaire Countertop Portable and EFIC123-SS list 1.5 lb.

Choose by how much ice you want available before you need to transfer it.

What counter space should you plan?

Measure the appliance area in 3 directions, then compare those measurements with the product dimensions. The Retro Compact has the smallest stated cabinet here at 11.6 x 8.7 x 11.4 in, while the EFIC452-SS measures 14 x 11 x 15 in.

Leave practical access for adding water, reading the controls and draining the machine. A compact width does not always mean a shallow depth, so check every dimension.

How should you set up and care for a Frigidaire ice maker?

Place the machine on a suitable level counter, add water according to its tank design and allow the first batches to run as directed. Use the controls to select the ice size where that option is available.

Drain plugs make emptying easier on several Frigidaire models. Clean the water-contact areas regularly, remove ice when the basket is full and move finished ice to a freezer when you need it to remain solid.

If your machine is part of a refrigerator installation, use the matching replacement instructions instead of countertop setup steps. This guide on installing a water line for a smart refrigerator may help with the related water connection work, but confirm the requirements for your refrigerator.

What if a Frigidaire ice maker stops making ice?

If a Frigidaire ice maker stops making ice, first check water level, basket status, power and the selected controls.

A full basket, low-water alert or blocked water path can stop normal production.

Start with the simplest checks in order. Confirm the machine is plugged in and the control panel is on, then look at the water level and whether the basket is full.

If the basket is full, remove the ice and restart the cycle. If water is low, refill the tank to the marked level and avoid overfilling.

Check that the chosen ice size is set and that no lid or basket is sitting out of place. A misaligned basket can interrupt a cycle even when water and power look fine.

For a refrigerator model, verify that the replacement part matches the refrigerator model before removing anything. Our guide to why a Frigidaire refrigerator ice maker is not making ice covers common checks.

That step matters because a part that fits one Frigidaire or Kenmore model may not fit another. Use the model number and part number on the old unit as your main reference.

Do not treat a countertop machine like a freezer. Remove finished ice promptly if melting affects your use, and drain and clean the unit when you are finished with a batch.

If the machine still will not cycle after water, power and basket checks, stop and follow the model instructions. Continued use with a fault can waste water and leave old ice sitting in the basket.

Regular cleaning also prevents many no-ice problems. Empty the tank, wipe water-contact areas, and start fresh when the machine has been stored or used heavily.

Which Frigidaire ice maker should you buy?

Pick the Frigidaire Countertop Portable for the best balance of 26 lb output, 2 ice sizes, a 2.1 qt tank and simple LED controls.

Pick the EFIC452-SS for 40 lb daily output and clear square ice, or the Nurfosttek only when your refrigerator model and part number match.

For a blue compact design, choose the Retro Compact. For nugget ice, choose the EUHOMY instead of a Frigidaire bullet or square model.

If counter space is the main limit, the EFIC123-SS and Retro Compact deserve a close look because their stated cabinets are smaller. Measure depth and height as well as width, since a narrow machine can still be deep.

If you want a black finish with clear alerts for a full basket or low water, the EFIC128AMZBLK fits that brief. Its indicators help when the machine runs while you are busy elsewhere.

If you prefer clear squared cubes without moving to the 40 lb model, the EFIC189-Silver is the middle path. It keeps 26 lb daily output and adds a 2.2 lb basket.

Your best choice comes down to ice texture, output, counter space and whether you need a countertop appliance or a refrigerator replacement part. Buy for the ice you will actually use each week, not the largest number on the box.

Our top 3 picks at a glance

  1. 1 Frigidaire Countertop Portable
    Best for everyday countertop ice

    Frigidaire Countertop Portable

    9.6/10 our score

    See it on Amazon
  2. 2 EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop
    Best for chewable nugget ice

    EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop

    9.6/10 our score

    See it on Amazon
  3. 3 Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker
    Best for refrigerator replacement

    Nurfosttek 241798224 241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker

    9.5/10 our score

    See it on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Frigidaire ice maker for most homes?

The Frigidaire Countertop Portable is the best general choice for most homes because it makes up to 26 lb of bullet-shaped ice per day, offers 2 ice sizes and has a 2.1 qt water tank. Choose the EFIC452-SS instead if you want clear square ice and 40 lb daily output.

Does a Frigidaire countertop ice maker keep ice frozen?

No. A countertop ice maker makes ice but does not provide long-term frozen storage.

Ice can melt in the basket, so move it to a freezer when you need it to stay solid. The EFIC128AMZBLK and Retro Compact data make this point directly.

Which Frigidaire ice maker makes clear square ice?

The FRIGIDAIRE EFIC452-SS makes clear square ice and produces up to 40 lb per day. The EFIC189-Silver also makes clear squared cubes and produces up to 26 lb per day.

Both offer 2 ice sizes.

What is the difference between a Frigidaire ice maker and a refrigerator replacement ice maker?

A Frigidaire countertop ice maker is a separate appliance that sits on a counter and makes ice into a basket. A refrigerator replacement, such as the Nurfosttek 241798224, is designed to fit inside compatible refrigerator models, so model and part-number matching is required.

How often should you clean a Frigidaire ice maker?

Clean a countertop ice maker regularly, especially when it has been stored, used often or develops residue. Drain plugs on several Frigidaire models make emptying easier.

Follow the model instructions, keep water-contact areas clean and remove old ice before starting a fresh batch.