8 Best Maytag Refrigerator Ice Makers (November 2026)
The best Maytag refrigerator ice maker replacements include the Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker for a listed Maytag model match, the BTNTVEN 4389102 Refrigerator Ice Maker Sensor Control for an optics control repair, and the Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact for extra ice outside the fridge.
On this page (6 sections)
- Which Maytag refrigerator ice makers made this list?
- Best replacement ice makers for Maytag refrigerators
- How do you match a replacement ice maker to a Maytag model?
- When should you replace an assembly instead of a sensor board?
- Can a countertop ice maker cover a repair delay?
- Which Maytag ice maker should you choose?
The best Maytag refrigerator ice maker replacement depends on your exact model and the part number it needs. Start with the Whirlpool WPW10190965 if your refrigerator model matches, then compare the other assemblies and control parts below; countertop machines are temporary separate ice sources, not built-in replacements.
An ice maker may stop because of the assembly, its level-sensing control, or a water supply issue. Diagnose the cause first with these ice maker troubleshooting and repair tips, then check the refrigerator’s full model number before you choose a part.
Our picks at a glance
-
1
Best for a listed Maytag model matchWhirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for an optics control repairBTNTVEN 4389102 Refrigerator Ice Maker Sensor Control
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for extra ice outside the fridgeFrigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact
9.4/10 our score
See it on Amazon
- 4
Check itFRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker
Best for a black countertop option - 5
Check itSupplying Demand D7824706Q Refrigerator Ice Maker Plug
Best for a D7824706Q model match - 6
Check itMintu W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces
Best for a broad older-model list - 7
Check itClimaTek Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965
Best for listed D7824706Q models - 8
Check itFRIGESWIFT 2198597 RIM597 Ice Maker Replacement Kit
Best for a 2198597 number match
Which Maytag refrigerator ice makers made this list?
The best Maytag refrigerator ice maker choices here are selected by part-number and model compatibility, with separate picks for sensor controls and temporary countertop ice. We compared the stated compatibility and included parts, since the right fit matters more than a long list of replacement numbers.
Scores weigh specs, features and buyer feedback against what you’re shopping for. A replacement part number is a useful clue, but it does not confirm a match unless your refrigerator model is covered.
| Product | Best for | Part number | Replaces | Included | Our score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker | a listed Maytag model match | WPW10190965 | W10190965, W11381372 and other part numbers | Ice mold, body and control device | 9.7 |
| BTNTVEN 4389102 Refrigerator Ice Maker Sensor Control | an optics control repair | 4389102 | Emitter board, receiver board and instruction sheet | 9.6 | |
| Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact | extra ice outside the fridge | 9.4 | |||
| FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker | a black countertop option | 9.3 | |||
| Supplying Demand D7824706Q Refrigerator Ice Maker Plug | a D7824706Q model match | D7824706Q | 9.0 | ||
| Mintu W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces | a broad older-model list | W10300022 / WPW10300022 | 8.7 | ||
| ClimaTek Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 | listed D7824706Q models | 8.5 | |||
| FRIGESWIFT 2198597 RIM597 Ice Maker Replacement Kit | a 2198597 number match | 2198597 / RIM597 | 8.1 |
Best replacement ice makers for Maytag refrigerators
These replacement parts cover different model groups and repair needs, so treat every fit as model-specific. The model number on your refrigerator is the final check before choosing an assembly or control.
Whirlpool WPW10190965: Best for a listed Maytag model match
Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker: Best for a listed Maytag model match
- Genuine Whirlpool OEM assembly
- Fits some Maytag models
- Replaces W10190965 and W11381372
- Shut-off arm and front cover not included
This genuine Whirlpool assembly fits some Maytag refrigerators. Check the complete model number and note that the shut-off arm and front cover are not included.
Pros
- Genuine Whirlpool assembly
- Multiple replacement part numbers
- Core ice-making assembly included
Cons
- Fits only some Maytag models
- Shut-off arm and front cover not included
The Whirlpool WPW10190965 is the lead choice because it is a genuine Whirlpool ice maker assembly and is stated to fit some Maytag models. It replaces several related part numbers, including W10190965 and W11381372, which can help when the old label uses one of those numbers.
The assembly includes the ice mold, body and control device. The shut-off arm and front cover are not included, so check whether you can reuse those parts from your existing unit or need to source them separately.
This assembly receives water from the inlet valve, holds it in the mold until frozen, then ejects and refills automatically. That makes it the relevant choice when the assembly itself is the failed part and the model cross-reference checks out.
BTNTVEN 4389102: Best for an optics control repair
BTNTVEN 4389102 Refrigerator Ice Maker Sensor Control: Best for an optics control repair
- Emitter and receiver boards
- Fits some Maytag models
- Replaces 4389102 and several related numbers
- Not a genuine Whirlpool part
This two-board kit is for an ice-level optics repair, not a replacement ice maker assembly. Confirm both the refrigerator model and the old control part number.
Pros
- Emitter and receiver included
- Maytag compatibility is stated
- Several replacement numbers are covered
Cons
- Not a genuine Whirlpool part
- Compatibility still needs model confirmation
This kit is for a different repair path: it includes an emitter and receiver board that detect the ice level in the bin. If the optics signal incorrectly reads the bin as full, the ice maker may stop cycling even when the assembly is intact.
The kit states compatibility with Maytag and several other brands, and it replaces a range of control part numbers. It is not a genuine Whirlpool part, so confirm the refrigerator model and old board number before ordering.
If you are still deciding whether a reset or a repair is the next step, read how to reset the ice maker on a smart refrigerator. A reset can help with a temporary control issue, but it does not make an incompatible board fit.
Frigidaire portable compact: Best for extra ice outside the fridge
Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact: Best for extra ice outside the fridge
- Portable countertop ice maker
- Makes up to 26 lb per day
- 9 bullet-shaped cubes per 7-minute cycle
- 2 ice sizes
This Frigidaire makes ice on the counter rather than repairing a Maytag refrigerator. It can provide a separate ice source while you diagnose or replace the built-in unit.
Pros
- Separate ice supply
- Two cube sizes
- Drain plug for emptying and cleaning
Cons
- Does not replace a refrigerator assembly
- Counter space and water refills are needed
This Frigidaire is a countertop machine, not a Maytag replacement assembly. It makes up to 26 lb of ice per day, with 9 bullet-shaped cubes per 7-minute cycle and two cube-size choices, so it can cover drinks while the built-in unit is being diagnosed.
Its 2.1 qt water tank and drain plug are useful details if you want a temporary independent source of ice. It does not repair the refrigerator or connect to its existing ice bin.
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK: Best for a black countertop option
FRIGIDAIRE EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop Ice Maker: Best for a black countertop option
- Portable countertop ice maker
- Makes up to 26 lb per day
- 9 cubes per 5–6-minute cycle
- Ice must be transferred to a freezer
This portable unit provides a separate ice source while a Maytag refrigerator is being repaired. It makes ice but does not keep it frozen, so transfer batches to a freezer.
Pros
- Separate ice supply
- Compact countertop format
- Alerts for a full basket or low water
Cons
- Does not replace a refrigerator assembly
- Ice needs prompt freezer transfer
This compact countertop option makes up to 26 lb per day and produces 9 cubes per 5–6-minute cycle. It can help keep ice available during a repair, but it is not a built-in Maytag part.
The machine does not keep finished ice frozen. Move each batch to a freezer promptly if you want to avoid melting, and account for the countertop footprint before setting it up.
Supplying Demand D7824706Q: Best for a D7824706Q model match
Supplying Demand D7824706Q Refrigerator Ice Maker Plug: Best for a D7824706Q model match
- Model-specific ice maker part
- Maytag GB6526FEAS10 appears in compatible models
- Plug connection is not universal
- Harness not included
This model-specific part includes a Maytag model match, but its plug connection is not universal. Confirm your full refrigerator model and connection before ordering.
Pros
- A specific Maytag model is named
- Alternate part numbers are included
- Original harness may be reusable
Cons
- Plug connection is not universal
- Harness is not included
Supplying Demand’s D7824706Q is model-specific, and its compatibility information names Maytag GB6526FEAS10. The plug connection is not universal, so use that model reference and the old part number as checks rather than assuming the part fits every Maytag refrigerator.
The harness is not included, though the original harness may be reusable. Verify the connector and the full refrigerator model before buying, especially if your old assembly carries a different part number.
Mintu W10300022: Best for a broad older-model list
Mintu W10300022 WPW10300022 Refrigerator Ice Maker Replaces: Best for a broad older-model list
- Fits specific Whirlpool-manufactured refrigerators
- Multiple Maytag models are named
- Cord is not included
- Head cover, bail arm, water trough and instructions included
Mintu names several Maytag refrigerator models and related replacement numbers. Compare the exact model and plan to reuse the old cord if your installation needs one.
Pros
- Specific Maytag model numbers are provided
- Several related part numbers are covered
- Bail arm is included
Cons
- Cord is not included
- Fit is limited to specific models
Mintu’s W10300022 assembly names multiple Maytag models, including MZD2766GEQ, MFD2560HES and MSD2454GRQ. It also covers several related part numbers, which makes it a candidate when an older refrigerator’s existing assembly carries a cross-reference in that family.
The cord is not included, but the old cord can be removed and reused. The listed contents include a head cover, bail arm, water trough and instructions, so check the existing wiring and parts before starting an installation.
ClimaTek bare ice maker: Best for listed D7824706Q models
ClimaTek Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965: Best for listed D7824706Q models
- Fits specific Maytag models
- Also identified with WPW10190965 and D7824706Q numbers
- Bare ice maker assembly
ClimaTek lists a set of Maytag models and several related part numbers. Use the model list as a cross-check, then verify the old assembly number before buying.
Pros
- Maytag models are named
- Multiple related part numbers are covered
- Bare assembly format
Cons
- Sparse installation details
- Specific model matching is essential
ClimaTek’s bare ice maker is tied to WPW10190965 and D7824706Q part families, and its compatibility information names specific Maytag models such as MFD2560HES and MSD2756GEW. That makes it a possible option when both the refrigerator model and old part number match.
The available details give less installation guidance than some other picks. Confirm what components your refrigerator requires and whether your old unit’s accessories can be reused before choosing a bare assembly.
FRIGESWIFT 2198597: Best for a 2198597 number match
FRIGESWIFT 2198597 RIM597 Ice Maker Replacement Kit: Best for a 2198597 number match
- Replaces 2198597, RIM597 and related numbers
- Maytag compatibility is stated
- Does not include a lifting arm
- Freezer must reach 3°F before operation
This kit is a possible fit when the old part number matches 2198597 or RIM597. Check whether your setup needs a lifting arm, since one is not included.
Pros
- Related replacement numbers are stated
- Maytag compatibility is stated
- Installation instructions included
Cons
- No lifting arm included
- Freezer temperature requirement applies
FRIGESWIFT identifies this kit with 2198597 and RIM597, among related replacement numbers, and states compatibility with Maytag. Match those numbers against your old ice maker and refrigerator model before treating it as a fit.
The kit does not include a lifting arm, and its instructions say the freezer must reach 3°F before the ice maker starts. Keep both details in mind when checking the old assembly and planning the repair.
How do you match a replacement ice maker to a Maytag model?
Match the complete refrigerator model number first, then use the old ice maker’s part number to narrow the options. Two parts can share a brand or a replacement number while still fitting different refrigerator models or connectors.
Locate the model label inside the fresh food section or freezer. Copy every letter and digit, including the suffix, because a partial model number may group together versions that use different parts.
Compare that number with the replacement’s compatibility details. For example, the Supplying Demand part names Maytag GB6526FEAS10, while Mintu and ClimaTek name specific Maytag model groups for their assemblies.
Next, inspect the old part label and connector. Confirm whether you need an assembly, an optics board kit, a harness, an arm or a cover, since those components are not interchangeable.
When should you replace an assembly instead of a sensor board?
Choose an assembly when the ice-making unit itself is the part that needs replacement, and choose an optics board kit only when the control system’s ice-level sensing is the repair target. Symptoms alone may not identify the failed part, so inspect the water supply and bin controls too.
A full or blocked bin can stop production by interrupting the ice-level signal. A closed water valve, kinked line or frozen fill tube can also prevent water from reaching the mold, so replacing an assembly will not solve every no-ice problem.
For more repair steps, see our replacement ice makers and parts for GE Profile refrigerators and Samsung Family Hub ice maker replacements guides. Their model-specific approach is useful across brands: identify the refrigerator and part before ordering.
Can a countertop ice maker cover a repair delay?
A countertop ice maker can provide separate ice while your built-in Maytag unit is out of service, but it is not a refrigerator replacement part. Both Frigidaire options here make up to 26 lb per day, with different cycle times and designs.
Choose the EFIC128AMZBLK if the black compact format suits your counter and you can move finished ice into a freezer promptly. The stainless portable model offers two cube sizes and a 2.1 qt tank, which may be useful if you want a separate appliance for gatherings.
If you are shopping for a new refrigerator rather than a repair, compare complete units in our best smart refrigerator with an ice maker guide. For add-on kits, see best ice maker kits for smart refrigerators.
Which Maytag ice maker should you choose?
Choose the Whirlpool WPW10190965 when your exact Maytag model is among the compatible models and the part number matches. Pick the BTNTVEN optics kit for a confirmed sensor-board repair, and use the D7824706Q or W10300022 options only when the model and old-part cross-check agree.
Use a countertop Frigidaire if you need separate ice while arranging a repair. For any built-in replacement, verify the model suffix, connector and included accessories before ordering.
Our top 3 picks at a glance
-
1
Best for a listed Maytag model matchWhirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for an optics control repairBTNTVEN 4389102 Refrigerator Ice Maker Sensor Control
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for extra ice outside the fridgeFrigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact
9.4/10 our score
See it on Amazon
Frequently asked questions
How do I find the right Maytag refrigerator ice maker?
Find the refrigerator’s complete model number on its identification label, then compare it with the replacement part’s compatibility information. Check the old ice maker’s part number as a second reference.
A brand match alone is not enough because several replacements fit only specific Maytag models.
Can I use a Whirlpool ice maker in a Maytag refrigerator?
Some Whirlpool parts fit some Maytag refrigerators, but compatibility depends on the exact model and part number. The WPW10190965 assembly is stated to fit some Maytag models.
Check the complete model number and required accessories before ordering.
Should I replace the ice maker or the sensor board?
Replace the part that matches the fault and your refrigerator’s design. An optics board kit controls ice level in the bin, while an ice maker assembly handles filling, freezing and ejecting ice.
If the cause is unclear, use a repair guide or qualified technician before buying parts.
Are countertop ice makers replacements for Maytag refrigerator parts?
No. Countertop ice makers make ice separately and do not fit inside or repair a refrigerator.
They can provide ice while the built-in unit is out of service, but they need counter space and a separate routine for moving the ice to a freezer.
About this guide: Our look at Maytag refrigerator ice maker replacements draws on maker specs, materials and what owners report. See how we research.



